I suppose that Super Butterfly Wuyi makes an odd yancha to begin Wuyi week with, especially since I have no idea what varietal it is. If I were to venture a guess, I might go with Huang Guan Yin, since it’s tightly rolled, seems to do better with less leaf than a typical yancha, and behaves somewhat like a medium-roast TGY. Perhaps the good folks at David’s Tea could chime in, or if MarshalN is reading, he probably knew what it was before the image finished loading (yes, MarshalN is the Chuck Norris of tea).
In any event, while I can’t tell you what it is, I can tell you how it tastes, although you can’t taste it for yourself until it’s restocked, if it ever is.
Using too much leaf (5 grams/100 mL), even with pretty short times, it’s not very good at all, at least not for more than a couple infusions. The words “metallic astringency” should be enough to convey the quality of the session. When my wrong fu is particularly bad, especially with a new tea, I like to take a step back, brew English-style, and give a second look. Fortunately, David’s Tea included directions right on the bag, and astonishingly they were right on the money.
A little less than 1 tsp per 5 oz at 194°F for three minutes delivered up a gentle yellow liquor that almost seemed too light, but a big, sweet cloud of aroma suggested otherwise. Its flavor was softer-toned than most other yancha I’ve had, like a cross between medium-roast Tie Guan Yin and Tie Luo Han, with a long note of buttery brown sugar, a floral fade-in, and a sweet, lingering finish. A second infusion was more floral, though not in any way depleted, while a third was promptly dumped down the sink.
Overall I liked this tea. Hopefully someone can tell me what it is.



9 Comments
Permalink
Interesting blog post! Quite thorough, by the way I really like your site’s design! :)
Permalink
Hooray! Wuyi week–my favorite!
Permalink
Chuck Norris? Oh dear…
This isn’t Wuyi though, whatever it is. Huang Guanyin isn’t a traditional Wuyi varietal. It was developed in the late 1970s onwards as a new breed, and is mostly there for the purpose of raising production. From what I’ve seen anyway, it’s usually produced like a Shuixian and not rolled like this.
Much more likely is Benshan or Huangjingui — with Benshan being a pretty likely possibility. How much was the tea?
Permalink
Pat - Thanks. I just added Crispy Tea Leaf to my blog directory. At some point I’ll incorporate a vlog section.
Zero - It’s rapidly becoming one of my favorites as well. Something Smuggled In was also added to my blog list.
Permalink
Thanks for your assessment, Marshal. I knew you would have some idea what this was.
After tasting more Wuyi this week, this tea tastes less and less like one. Benshan seems a distinct possibility.
I received it as a sample for review, so I’m not quite sure of the price. If I recall correctly, it was $15/25g.
Permalink
$15/25g?!?!?
I want some of that free money.
Permalink
Thanks for the blog add, Lewis! I’ve got some Yen Cha posts brewing…MarshalN, if you’re out there–I’m confused about one point in your post. Are you saying this tea is not a Wuyi because it might be Huang Guan Yin? I was under the assumption that Huang Guan Yin is still a yen cha, even if it was invented recently. Or, are you just saying you don’t think this tea is Huang Guan Yin?
Permalink
I read Marshal’s comment to mean that Huang Guan Yin simply isn’t a traditional Wuyi varietal, thus not really a Wuyi, even though it may be grown in the region and processed as a yancha. I could be mistaken.
Permalink
Lewis is more or less right in his interpretation - if I have a new grape varietal and start growing it in Burgundy tomorrow for wine, does that make my wine a Burgundy? The French would say no. If you plant a Yunnan tea tree in Wuyi and start making tea Wuyi style with that Yunnan big leaf tree, is that Wuyi? I personally don’t think so.
Besides, this isn’t even processed like a traditional Wuyi (low roast, rolled into ball shape, etc), so it’s a moot point.